In May 1987, the body of young Teresa McAbee was found in a lake, causing tremors in the small town of Mascotte, Florida. As the authorities work to solve the murder, they realize the evidence points to one of their own.
“The Killer in Question: The Girl in the Lake,” an investigation uncovered, delves into Teresa’s murder and how most of the circumstantial evidence led to the conviction of a police officer. So if you’re wondering what happened to Teresa, we’ve got you covered. How did Teresa McCabe die? Theresa McCabe was born in July 1975. The 11-year-old girl was in the fifth grade at Mascot Elementary School at the time of the incident.
On May 11, 1987, around 10 p.m., Teresa left her house to go to a nearby store because she wanted to buy a pencil. However, she never returned.
Teresa’s mother went to the store around 11 p.m. and eventually filed a missing person report. The next day, a fisherman found the body of a young woman sunk face down in Knights Lake in Mascot.
she is teresa she was dressed and the lake was less than a mile from the store where she was last seen. The medical examiner confirmed that Teresa was sexually assaulted, then strangled and drowned. There was blood on her underwear and semen on her jeans. Additionally, a pubic hair was selected from Teresa’s panties.
- Justin Murdock
- Bethany Martin
- Eva Padlock
- Nancy Momoland On
- Andrea Pascuzzi
- Kim Lamarin
- Sidemen Sunday
Who killed Teresa McCabe? Investigations revealed that Teresa left the store with a 16-year-old boy after buying a pencil. She was then approached by a patrol officer, James Duckett. He is a rookie and part of Mascot’s five-man force.
It’s about when Teresa was last seen. In the immediate vicinity of where the body was found, several tire tracks led police to a major discovery. The markings are made from specific tires found on just two Mascotte patrol cars. The only officer on patrol when Teresa disappeared was the 29-year-old rookie.
James said he just talked to Teresa outside the store and told her to go home. The 16-year-old later testified that James approached him and Teresa while they were talking. He then put Teresa in the passenger seat of his squad car. The clerk also said that James walked in and asked for Teresa’s name and age.
Also, Teresa’s palm print was found on the hood of James’s car, as if she had ever sat there. But after James was arrested, he denied that Theresa was sitting on the hood of his car. Although the evidence against James was circumstantial, expert testimony about the pubic hair soon changed. FBI agent and hair test expert Michael Malone testified that the pubic hair likely belonged to James.
There were other testimonies, in which three teenagers testified that James tried to kiss them in his police car. However, he denied that these events occurred. Later, Gwen Gurley testified that she saw James and Teresa walking away together. Although she later retracted her testimony, she later claimed that she was forced to do so.
It’s about when Teresa was last seen. Near where her body was found, several tire tracks led police to an important discovery. The markings are made with specific tires found only on two Mascotte patrol cars. The only officer on patrol when Teresa disappeared was the 29-year-old rookie.
James said he just talked to Teresa outside the store and told her to go home. The 16-year-old later testified that James approached him and Teresa while they were talking. He then put Teresa in the passenger seat of his police car. The clerk also said that James walked in and asked for Teresa’s name and age.
